Quote.
Source: http://sacred-texts.com/hin/m11/m11018.htm
=
The seven sons of thine that were thus slain were Satrunjaya, Satrusaha, Chitra, Chitrayudha, Dridha, Chitrasena & Vikarna. Amongst all thy sons thus slain, Vrikodara, the son of Pandu, grieved bitterly from sorrow for Vikarna who was dear to him. Bhima said "Even thus was the vow made by me, that all of you should be slain by me in battle. It is for that, O Vikarna, that thou hast been slain. My vow hath been accomplished. O hero, thou camest to battle, bearing in mind the duties of a Kshatriya. Thou wert ever engaged in our good & especially in that of the king (our eldest brother). It is scarcely proper, therefore, for me to grieve for thy illustrious self." Having slain those princes in the very sight of Radha's son, the son of Pandu uttered a terrible leonine roar.
Point: Bhima said Vikarna was ever engaged in their good especially of the king (their eldest brother [either Karna or Yudhishthira, both of them were kings] because he saved Karna's life twice), but that is considered a later interpolation as it has been removed by BORI Mahabharata.
======
"Thy heroic son Vikarna, deprived of steeds and weapons, stood, facing the foe, remembering the duties of Kshatriyas. Remembering the many foul wrongs inflicted upon him by Duryodhana & bearing in mind his own vow, Bhimasena hath slain him."
Analysis: Sanjaya claims that Vikarna had no weapons when he died.
- Described by Gandhari in Stri Parva
There, O Madhava, my son Vikarna, applauded by the wise, lieth on the bare ground, slain by Bhima and mangled horribly! Deprived of life, O slayer of Madhu, Vikarna lieth in the midst of (slain) elephants like the moon in the autumnal sky surrounded by blue clouds. His broad palm, cased in leathern fence, and scarred by constant wielding of the bow, is pierced with difficulty by vultures desirous of feeding upon it. His helpless young wife, O Madhava, is continually endeavouring, without success, to drive away those vultures desirous of feeding on carrion. The youthful and brave and handsome Vikarna, O bull among men, brought up in luxury and deserving of every kind of weal, now sleepeth amid the dust, O Madhava! Though all his vital parts have been pierced with clothyard shafts and bearded arrows and nalikas, yet that beauty of person which was his hath not forsaken this best of the Bharatas.
Analysis: Gandhari (even though she was blindfolded) claimed that Vikarna's corpse was mangled and left to rot in the midst of dead elephants on the ground. She claims he was killed in an archery battle.
=
VIKARNA.
14th day.
[start]
The seven sons of thine that were thus slain were Satrunjaya, and Satrusaha, and Chitra, and Chitrayudha, and Dridha, and Chitrasena and Vikarna. Amongst all thy sons thus slain, Vrikodara, the son of Pandu, grieved bitterly from sorrow for Vikarna who was dear to him.
14th night.
What Drona did (lighting lamp's);
"Indeed, all the troops, thus made radiant by the foot-soldiers with oil-fed lamps in their hands, looked beautiful like clouds in the nocturnal sky illumined by flashes of lightning. When the Kuru host had thus been illuminated, Drona, endued with the effulgence of fire, scorching everything around, looked radiant, O king, in his golden armour, like the midday sun of blazing ray. The light of those lamps began to be reflected from the golden ornaments, the bright cuirasses and bows, and the well-tempered weapons of the combatants."
{complete}
Suyodhana talked to Vikarna.
[quote]
Understanding the wishes of Drona who was bent on battle, Duryodhana, on that night addressing his obedient brothers, Vikarna and Chitrasena and Suparsva and Durdharsha and Dirghavahu, and said "Ye heroes of great valour, struggling with resolution, all of you protect Drona from the rear. The son of Hridika will protect his right and Sala his left." Saying this, thy son then urged forward placing them at the van.
=
Conclusion: So all three descriptions differ in certain ways. All of them agree that Bhima killed Vikarna, two of them say that he was killed in an archery battle, one of them says that he was unarmed when he was slain.
Regarding the mention of vikarna on the 14th night it can be considered either a clerical error or a inaccuracy in mahabharat.
Ashwathama was older than Yudhishthira and thus he was also older than Arjuna.
ReplyDeleteNarrative:
O glorious Krishna, salute her for me, the Kuru king Dhritarashtra also, and all those monarchs who are senior to us in age, and Bhishma, and Drona, and Kripa, and king Vahlika, and Drona's son and Somadatta, and in fact, every one of the Bharata race, and also Vidura endued with great wisdom, that counsellor of the Kurus, of profound intellect and intimate acquaintance with morality,--should all, O slayer of Madhu, be embraced by thee!'http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/m05/m05083.htm
Krishna talks about the offer made to Karna. Krishan tells Yudhishthira he made the offers to karna only to make peace.
ReplyDeleteNarrative:
O lord, rebuking all the kings, making a straw of Suyodhana, terrifying Radha's son and repeatedly censuring Suvala's son for the gambling match of Dhritarashtra's sons, and once again endeavouring to disunite all the kings by means of both words and intrigues, I again had recourse to conciliation. For the unity of Kuru's race and in view of the special requirements of the business (at hand), I spoke also of gift. Indeed, I said, 'Those heroes, the sons of Pandu, sacrificing their pride, will live in dependence on Dhritarashtra, Bhishma and Vidura. Let the kingdom be given to thee. Let them have no power. Let: it all be as the king (Dhritarashtra), as Ganga's son (Bhishma) and as Vidura say for thy good. Let the kingdom be thine. Relinquish but five villages (to the Pandavas). O best of kings, without doubt they deserve to be supported by thy father. http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/m05/m05150.htm
As per later event (according to Bhishma) Karna was also captured by the Gandharvas and liberated by Arjuna during the ghosh yatra.
ReplyDeleteNarrative:
On the occasion also of the tale of cattle, when captured by the Gandharvas, this Karna and all these thy counsellors and thyself accoutred in mail and on thy car, were all liberated from the grasp of the Gandharvas by that Arjuna. http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/m05/m05138.htm